Alameda County
Bar Association

Proceed with Caution: Why Clients with a History of Multiple Attorneys May Pose Challenges 

Taking on a new client is a significant decision for any attorney, and it’s essential to evaluate potential clients carefully to ensure a positive and productive attorney-client relationship. While every client deserves quality representation, attorneys should exercise caution when considering clients with a history of working with multiple attorneys. While not necessarily indicative of the client’s character or the merits of their case, this pattern may raise red flags and present challenges that warrant careful consideration.

proceed with caution Why Clients with a History of Multiple Attorneys May Pose Challenges client managementHere are several reasons why a client who has been through multiple attorneys might not be a good fit:

1. Communication Issues: Clients who have worked with multiple attorneys may need help communicating effectively or maintaining open lines of communication. This could be due to various factors, including unrealistic expectations, poor listening skills, or a lack of trust in the legal process. Attorneys rely on clear and consistent communication to effectively represent their clients, and clients who need help in this area may pose challenges.

2. Unrealistic Expectations: Clients who have been through multiple attorneys may have unrealistic expectations about the outcome of their case or the role of their attorney. This could stem from previous experiences with attorneys who made promises they couldn’t deliver on or failed to effectively manage the client’s expectations. Clients with unrealistic expectations may be demanding to satisfy and may ultimately be dissatisfied with the outcome of their case, regardless of the attorney’s efforts.

3. Trust Issues: Clients who have worked with multiple attorneys may have trust issues or need more confidence in the legal profession. This could result from past experiences with attorneys who could have communicated more effectively, provided competent representation, or acted in the client’s best interests. Rebuilding trust with a client who has been burned by previous attorneys can be challenging and may require additional time and effort on the part of the attorney.

4. Personality Conflicts: Clients who have gone through multiple attorneys may have difficulty establishing rapport or maintaining positive relationships with their legal counsel. This could be due to personality conflicts, differences in communication styles, or incompatible expectations. Attorneys rely on solid attorney-client relationships built on trust, respect, and mutual understanding, and clients who struggle to connect with their attorneys may pose challenges.

5. History of Disputes: Clients who have worked with multiple attorneys may have a history of disputes, conflicts, or disagreements with their legal representation. This could indicate underlying issues with the client’s behavior, communication style, or expectations, which may present challenges for future attorneys. Attorneys must assess the risks associated with taking on a client with a track record of disputes with previous attorneys.

While clients who have been through multiple attorneys deserve quality representation and a fair chance to have their legal issues addressed, you must approach these cases with caution. While not inherently indicative of the client’s character or the merits of their case, a history of working with multiple attorneys may raise red flags and present challenges that warrant careful consideration. Attorneys should carefully evaluate potential clients, assess the risks, and determine whether taking on the representation is in their best interests and the client’s best interests.